Defend Bear Butte!DefendBearButte.org



 

Loud Pipes and Sacred Pipes; the Need for Reconciliation
By Eileen Hanson | Guest Opinion
Winona Daily News
August 8, 2006

 
I can appreciate Jim Galewski’s thoughts on loud pipes in the bluffs. I live on Broadway, and the roar of motorcycles at all hours day and night is one of the sounds of summer I can do without. Until recently, I thought of it as just one of those things you have to put up with for the few months of warm weather each year. But for some, the culture of loud pipes as well as the drinking and loud music that often accompanies them, is more than an annoyance. For many of our American Indian neighbors, they pose a very real threat to their sacred spaces.

Bear Butte is a majestic place that rises out of the South Dakota plain, just east of the Black Hills. For more than 30 indigenous nations, including the Lakota and Cheyenne, Bear Butte is a sacred place. Native people continue to gather there for ceremonies, to fast and pray and seek guidance from the Great Spirit, as they have for centuries.

Today that sacred place is danger of being overrun by the nearby Sturgis motorcycle rally. This year, Sturgis expects to attract more than 600,000 bikers during a five-day music festival. Bear Butte is now virtually surrounded by concert venues and campgrounds catering to the biker crowds. A recently built amphitheater, Buffalo Chip, is just a short distance away. Worshipers at Bear Butte can hear clearly the loud music and every filthy word that emanates from that place. A similar venue is scheduled to break ground soon on the other side of the mountain. A campground that lies at the base of Bear Butte has latrines on the slope of the sacred mountain and, with an eye to expansion, has just applied for and been issued a beer license.

In light of these threats to Bear Butte, a summit of elders from many tribes will convene there this week to discuss Indian land rights, and, specifically, protection of sacred spaces. The immediate goal for Bear Butte is the enactment and enforcement of a five-mile buffer zone to protect the prayerful quiet of the mountain.

Even the town of Sturgis has reason to be ambivalent about the rally. For this town of 6,000 to absorb more than half a million bikers, everything must be geared to motorcycles, and in particular a culture of loud pipes, loud music and drinking indicative of this rally. In Sturgis, there are countless biker bars and saloons. Many residents and businesses not related to the rally simply vacate during the festival. One local store even moves its entire inventory into storage, and the space is converted into a biker bar for five days because the absentee landlord can reap such profits in that short time. Huge sums of money change hands during the festival, but with increasing outside ownership and investment, it’s not clear how much of that actually stays in the small town of Sturgis.

The reputation for law-breaking and loud partying is not indicative of all bikers, or everyone at the Sturgis rally. In particular, many bikers are very respectful of American Indian culture and spirituality. One group, Bikers USA, has endorsed the call to protect Bear Butte, and native people are encouraged by such support. The real threat to Bear Butte is not the bikers themselves, but the greed that feeds the development boom surrounding the rally.

Winona has begun a great tradition in the past few years with the Dakota Homecoming. Seeing how many Dakota people travel to Winona for the homecoming, we can begin to understand the importance of the land to Lakota culture and spirituality. In opening our community to our predecessors and neighbors on this prairie, we have begun a process of reconciliation long overdue. As motorcycle season continues and we see and hear bikers passing through Winona on their way to Sturgis, let’s hope that we can all find a ways to encourage dialogue and respect for all our neighbors.

Eileen Hanson is a member of the Winona Catholic Worker community. “In the interests of full disclosure, I freely admit that my favorite kind of bike is a bicycle.”

Guest views are opinions of the author and don’t necessarily reflect the views of the Winona Daily News. They are published to stimulate thought and to provide an expanded forum on issues of local interest.

 

NOTE: In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107, this material is distributed without profit or payment to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving this information for non-profit research and educational purposes only.

Google
Search WWW Search defendbearbutte.org

Bear Butte

Main Page | Statements | News Articles | History | Call to Bikers/Vets | Links | Contact Us | Guestbook

©2005 Inter-Tribal Coalition to Defend Bear Butte